top of page
  • marketing68650

5 Instances Where Crisis Management and Leadership Significantly Impacted a Company

5 Instances Where Crisis Management and Leadership Significantly Impacted a Company

In the realm of business, effective crisis management can be the linchpin of survival and success. We've gathered insights from CEOs and founders to explore five pivotal moments where leadership decisively navigated through turmoil. From embracing change during regulatory shifts to the renowned Johnson & Johnson's swift action that saved lives, discover the critical decisions that left indelible marks on their companies.

  • Embrace Change in Regulatory Shifts

  • Domino's Recipe and Brand Revival

  • BP Oil Spill: CEO's Crisis Mismanagement

  • Schultz's Starbucks Turnaround Strategy

  • Johnson & Johnson's Swift Action Saves Lives

Embrace Change in Regulatory Shifts

In our constantly evolving world, leadership and vision take many forms. I've been involved in a few notable situations where companies have been at pivotal moments, defining their future and ability to survive based 100% on external factors. It takes guts and a willingness to embrace change and do what it takes to reinvent oneself as needed. In one case, it involved a regulatory change that would, in effect, shut down or consolidate half of the industry. 

My boss and CEO at the time worked to bring in people who understood the new landscape and had the courage to shut down operations that wouldn't take us into the future and open up new locations that would. We went from a capable supplier to one that now dominates the global landscape in the new world. Companies today are similarly going through the process of navigating the world through the new lens of AI. 

Some firms in our industry are focused on a business-as-usual mentality, which will ultimately end up the same way—companies losing market share and getting shut down or bought out at a discount—but those who thrive will be those who embrace the change and provide their clients with an integrated AI solution, even at the risk of lost or reduced revenues. 

Those who navigate crises and have the courage to embrace change are those who thrive as horses and buggies get replaced by cars, cameras get replaced by phones, DVDs get replaced by streaming services, and people get enhanced or replaced by AI.

Domino's Recipe and Brand Revival

Domino's was once known as a restaurant that served low-quality pizza. In response to this criticism, it not only created a new recipe for its pizza, but it also created a new marketing campaign that admitted its pizza was low-quality before and explained that it had made major changes to its recipe. This marketing campaign resulted in a turnaround and long-term growth that helped Domino's outperform other pizzerias.

BP Oil Spill CEO's Crisis Mismanagement

During the 2010 BP oil spill crisis, CEO Tony Hayward's lack of empathy and poor crisis management skills led to a massive PR disaster for the company. His dismissive attitude and insensitive comments only fueled public outrage and damaged BP's reputation further. 

This incident highlights the importance of strong leadership during times of crisis, showing that a CEO's actions and words can have a significant impact on a company's image and success. As a CEO, it's crucial to show empathy, take responsibility, and communicate effectively to navigate through challenging situations and maintain trust with stakeholders.

Alex Stasiak, CEO and Founder, Startup House

Schultz's Starbucks Turnaround Strategy

In the early 2000s, Starbucks faced several challenges, including oversaturation of stores, declining customer experience, and the global financial crisis of 2008. The company's rapid expansion had led to a dilution of the brand, and there were concerns about declining sales and a tarnished reputation.

Leadership and Crisis Management: Howard Schultz, the founder and former CEO of Starbucks, recognized the urgency of the situation and returned to the role of CEO in 2008 after stepping down in 2000. He implemented a series of decisive actions to address the crisis and steer the company back to success:

Focus on the Customer Experience: Schultz emphasized the importance of the Starbucks experience. He believed that the company's success was rooted in the unique in-store environment and the personal connections that baristas had with customers. He aimed to restore that focus.

Temporary Store Closures: As part of a "Transformation Agenda," Schultz initiated a temporary closure of all Starbucks stores in the United States for a day to provide retraining to baristas. This demonstrated a commitment to quality and consistency.

Product Innovation: Starbucks introduced new products and innovations, such as the introduction of the Starbucks Rewards loyalty program and the expansion of the food menu to complement the coffee offerings.

Engagement with Employees: Schultz personally engaged with employees, conducting "open forums" to listen to their ideas, concerns, and suggestions. This demonstrated a commitment to employee well-being and involvement.

Under Schultz's leadership and crisis management approach, Starbucks managed to successfully navigate the crisis and achieve a remarkable turnaround. Schultz's emphasis on the Starbucks experience and customer relationships helped reinvigorate the brand and restore its reputation for quality. The company experienced a financial recovery, with increased sales and improved profitability.

Johnson & Johnson's Swift Action Saves Lives

One notable example of crisis management and leadership making a significant impact in a company is Johnson & Johnson's response to the Tylenol poisoning crisis in 1982. In September of that year, seven people in the Chicago area died after ingesting Tylenol capsules that had been laced with cyanide. This incident created widespread panic and raised serious concerns about the safety of over-the-counter medications.

Johnson & Johnson, the maker of Tylenol, faced a monumental challenge in restoring public trust and ensuring the safety of its products. In response, the company took swift and decisive action. Within days of the first deaths, Johnson & Johnson issued a nationwide recall of all Tylenol products, an unprecedented move at the time that cost the company millions of dollars.

In addition to the recall, Johnson & Johnson demonstrated exemplary crisis communication and transparency. The company kept the public informed through regular press briefings, took responsibility for the situation, and worked closely with law enforcement agencies to investigate the tampering.

Furthermore, Johnson & Johnson introduced tamper-evident packaging for its products, setting a new standard for safety in the pharmaceutical industry. These measures not only helped to prevent further harm but also reassured consumers that their safety was a top priority for the company.

The decisive actions taken by Johnson & Johnson's leadership during the Tylenol poisoning crisis not only saved lives but also preserved the company's reputation in the long term. Their commitment to transparency, accountability, and swift action in the face of adversity serves as a powerful example of effective crisis management and leadership.

Marissa Sabrina, Creative Director, LeadLearnLeap